Pounding The Rock: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: RSL Soapbox for Real Salt Lake Fans!

Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team! What an Accomplishment!

[Editor's note:  Another great recap by a PtR member, complete with Photoshop wizardry!  The DET game thread is posted below.]

Hmm...This is an odd emotion after a Spurs game. Is this....happiness? What!? You mean I'm not feeling bitter disappointment and anger? This is nice. I remember when this was a common feeling.

The  Jersey game was a beatdown pretty much from start to finish. Some might say that this was to be expected, look at everyone the Nets are missing! Spurs fans know better. This game had all the makings of a game won (or lost) at the FT line in the final minute. I was actually kinda shocked that the Spurs won by 20+....which shows how far this team has fallen in my eyes. But if Elson goes for 8 and 7 every night, Horry hits a shot or two, and Finley shoots 50% we are going to have a decent chance at making some noise in the playoffs. The Big 3 are continuing a high level of play, and Barry keeps chugging along. Now if we can get Bonner back playing well (he's cleared to play) we might have a good run in us. It'll take some luck falling our way, but stranger things have happened.

Everyone's favorite lazy fatass big man got 8 minutes of playing time tonight. Time that he did absolutely nothing with. Time that I got to watch James White sit on the bench in a suit.

You would think that after our guards constantly get shit upon in games that Pop would give this guy a CHANCE. I've heard a handful of reports that say this guy looks GREAT in practice. What more does he have to do to get a chance? Pop even got Linton Freaking Johnson some playing time (and then let him go so he could become a useful player for the NOOCH....not like we needed an athletic 3 though, right?). What a cocktease.

Pop then tells the Express-News that the Ely trade was "just one injured-list guy for another injured-list guy" and basically gave no indication that he would ever play him. Wow Pop, way to fucking go. You got rid of an excellent trade asset in Williams for just another player you won't play. Fuck you. Surely to God Williams/Beno or Williams/[who the fuck ever] could have gotten someone that YOU WOULD ACTUALLY PLAY. But oh no, we can't have someone taking minutes from Robert Horry or Michael Finley! That would be terrible! Not to mention, Pop goes with a 3 man bigman rotation, leaving Oberto rot until garbage time. Now, I'm not saying that Oberto is the best option we have, but all benching Oberto is going to do is have more minutes for small ball and all that's going to do is lose more games and get Pop's dick hard because Pop loves him some tinyball.

No, that is not innuendo you sick bastards.

Here's what I would like to see happen with the Spurs roster up til the playoffs

1.    Trade Beno. I don't care if its for a second rounder next decade, get rid of him.
2.    Move Brent to backup PG. We need some competency at that position.
3.    Start Manu and bench Bowen. Start Finley.
4.    Give White playing time as the 4th swingman in the rotation. If he sucks, then we can go back with Vaughn as the backup and put Barry in as the 2/3 again.
5.    Have the 4/5 rotation be Tim/Elson then Bonner/Ely. Ely can at least contribute some scoring since Pop has put Obby in the feared doghouse. Anything is better than small ball or Horry.
6.    The 8 man playoff rotation that Pop loves to adhere to should be:  Parker/Manu/Finley/Tim/Elson with Barry/Bonner/Bowen coming off the bench.

All this, I feel, would give the Spurs a decent chance to succeed. Rebounding would be a problem, but its going to suck anyway.

0 recs  |  Comment 32 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
You make some valid points and a great write up! I can't believe our retarded (and I mean no disrespect to the handicapped) coach is supposedly trading one guy who doesn't play for another guy who doesn't play. Great to hear that White is doing well in practice and not being allowed to dress.

Is Pop personally doing this to get himself a bigger contract?  

Thank god I missed the game last night, or I would have had to watch Butler play!  

by adam8065 on Feb 14, 2007 3:32 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
Re: Pop's boner for Finley.  These anti-doghouse players send everything spiralling downwards.  Instead of realizing he sucks and benching him a la Steve Smith, we play him, pursue trades involving other Spurs who are better than him, avoid developing young players, in short, Finley is the center of the problem.  Why couldn't we trade him?  "It's a business," says Pop.  But not for shitty players?  God, I wish we had just kept Glenn Robinson.  Honestly, yes.  He could at least hit a jumper.  He could post up.  How is that not better?  And he would have been cheaper, in case that somehow matters.

Re: Pop's comments about Ely.  I think Pop was just being "funny".  I do think Ely will get some minutes, if only because he's had a boner for Ely for awhile, supposedly.  However, his comments about Ely seem like a slap in the face.  His "self-deprecating wit" has descended into deprecating everyone around him.  Slam had a blog for the Wiz game where Pop acted like he didn't even know who White's name was.  Who the fuck jokes like this to the media?  I know some people think its amusing in the way Pop deals with the media (outright hostility) but it seems odd to me.  It's not "classy" - the word some fans like jerk off to.

The daily rant is over...for now.

by Jones on Feb 14, 2007 4:17 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
Remember when we traded for Nazr in 2003? What was the 1st thing out of Pop's mouth? Rasho's job is not in jeopardy.

Never trust Pop when it comes to playing time. Also, if Ely convinces Elson that his job is on the line, and gets him to play like he has tonight, it's all good.

One more thing, James, when was the last time you tried to play basketball after losing 30 lbs. It's awfully difficult if you can't outfat everyone for reboudns/position anymore. I still think Jackie Butler and Ian Minhami (who is struggling in Europe) are both solid-good prospects. So is James WHite. If anything, hammer pop for playing/dressing Beno when it is clear that he's a shooting guard in a PG's body.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 14, 2007 8:26 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
I'm guessing you have missed the articles from SA talking about how unmotivated and lazy Butler is.

by JamesR on Feb 14, 2007 9:07 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
You mean the shit from one beat reporter. Whoppidty fucking do. Ludden writes because he expects Butler to contribute this year, something that clearly wasn't happening when we broke with Oberto/Elson.

Look at a picture of him now and a picture of him when he was with the Knicks or during early-season. There's a world of difference. It's absolutely ridiculous to base your opinions from the opinions of Johnny Ludden.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 14, 2007 9:10 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
I partly base my opinions on that, and i partly base my opinions on watching Butler half-ass it when he gets on the court. When you aren't getting minutes, you should bust your fatass off when you get on the floor. Look at Beno! He doesn't play anymore but by God when he gets on the floor he busts his ass.

by JamesR on Feb 14, 2007 9:15 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
You must be watching another Beno Udrih on another Spurs team. That said, Butler has played a whopping 34 minutes this year. If you can make a judgement about a player in 34 mintues of eratic playing time, you should call Sam Presti right now, cause you deserve his job.

As I said, compare his body now to when he was playing with the Knicks. Right now, he looks mechanical, you know, like a guy who just dropped 30 lbs and is attempting to play basketball. Being mechanical doesn't equate to being half-assed.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 15, 2007 1:08 AM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
Finley is paying Pop, he has to be; or he must have some pictures of Pop doing some nasty things to wine bottles.

by adam8065 on Feb 14, 2007 4:30 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
Great blog.  I'm almost ashamed to post the link to mine now.  I agree with almost everything you said.  What sucks about Pop is that he loves Finley so much, but not enough to offset his love of Bruce.  

If only he could be made to understand that without two great shotblockers behind him, Bowen's completely useless.  

I think I found a perfect solution to all of our problems: We just gotta play musical chairs with some jobs so that nobody loses face.

Release Bowen and give him Sean Elliott's analyst job, where he'd be sensational.  

Fire Elliott and re-hire him as an assistant coach where he can constantly chirp in Pop's ear to give the ball to Tim or Manu.  

Give James White Bowen's spot in the rotation.

And have Chip Engalland and his sweet shooting stroke join our D-League team and be their "Microwave" off the bench.  

by Aaronstampler on Feb 14, 2007 4:36 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
While Bruce has certainly been a bit slower this year, his +/- numbers show that he's having his best defensive year since 2003. He'll always get lit up by guys like LeBron, Wade and Kobe. To say that he's useless, though, is quite an exaggeration - even for you.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 14, 2007 8:28 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
He has also been lit up by Adam Morrison, Mike Miller, Michael Redd, Andre Iguodala and many other players. It's ok he is 35 years old.

About Butler I'm sorry but he is lazy and fat. For someone to be playing basketball Since October  I guess that is when training camp started and still be this out of shape is pathetic. If he wanted to he could have gotten himself a nutritionist or ride a bicycle longer. There is no excuse for that

I am speaking from experience. I lost 40 pounds a couple of years ago, because I didn't like who I was becoming. Now I wasn't getting paid 2 million per year and having the best doctors around. His job is just to play basketball, and he isn't even in shape for that.
Until I can see that he is motivated he is a huge bust! And when he is out on the floor he doesn't seem to be able to do a damn thing correctly.

by adam8065 on Feb 14, 2007 9:43 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
That's great, but you weren't asked to play basketball, and I doubt you're 6'10".

He has already lost weight, the problem is, it's hard to get acclimated to a new body, especially for a player whose game was "establish position with bulk and overpower." Right now, he's getting used to his new body, it's not a question of Work Ethic, it's a question of familarity. That's why you don't make judgements about players based on 30 minutes of court time and the filtered musings of a beat writer. It tends to make you make horrible judgements, and I'm guessing everyone that's clamouring for James White haven't actually seen him play. Cause while he can dunk, 1) he rarely does so in games, 2) he was rarely the best player on his NBDL team and 3) despite playing in the NBDL and playing large minutes, he average 3.9 boards a game. That's horrible. Bruce Bowen like, even.

As far the idea of Bowen getting older, yeah, congrats, I already said "Every defensive stopper gets lit up by scorers once in awhile." You just named those scorers. The problem is, more often than not, he can stop the opposing team's best guy from going off, but we rarely remember those nights. Scorers get hot sometimes, and there is little a defender can do, especially streak shooters like Redd and Morrison. Does the fact that Manu absolutely tore apart the Pistons D in the 2005 Finals make that team a horrible defensive team? No. We play in league that favors offense, and defensive players will be prone to give up some big scoring nights. Bowen has done it every year, I don't see how this year is different.

However, more often than not, he does a great job of containing his guy, including guys like Butler, Marion, etc, but we rarely talk about his good nights. (Oh, and last time the Spurs played the Grizz, Miller was 4-13 with 13 pts. You have odd definitions of "Lit up")

Ultimately, I severely doubt White gives us anything more than Bowen does right now. That's why he's the understudy ala S-Jax circa 2002. Both White and Butler are on the S-Jax plan. To expect either of them to be contributors right now is rather unrealistic.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 15, 2007 1:19 AM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
Elton brand lost weight and became a star. I know he wasn't as big as Butler but who's fault is it for letting him get that big? Nobody is forcing Butler to eat bad foods. He needs to develop discipline and will power. If he can't control what he puts in his mouth, how he is going to be motivated or disciplined enough to work on his game?

by adam8065 on Feb 14, 2007 9:47 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
Well, after Kobe Bryant came back from his injury he  was a 30 pt scorer, the fact that Manu Ginobili didn't do that obviously means Manu is lazy and out-of-sorts.

This argument is dumb, as I said, if you look at the tapes of him in New York, and then compare to what we saw last night, you'd see he was much leaner, and a bit quicker. The problem is, that he is still playing like he is a 290 lb guy, when he's probably more around 250 right now. The problem isn't work ethic, it's familarity with his own body. This is why it would have been cool to be able to send him to the NBDL. He looked decent on rotations and looked alright when he was given the ball in the post(helped out, and did a decent job helping on funneled players, boxing out, etc, etc), so it looks like he's at least understanding the system. It would be interesting to see what he would do when he's allowed to become familiar with his new body shape.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 15, 2007 1:26 AM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
It seems like Scorers get extremely hot when Bowen is guarding him. So he is getting lit up more than you think. He can't stay with anyone anymore. The only people he can guard our players that can't create shots off the dribble. Example: Marion. Other players can go right by him. What Manu did was incredible, he was unstoppable. Now Bowen has been stinking it up all year. Next you are going to tell he is shooting lights out this year. The game before Miller lit him for 27 points in San Antonio. He is a year older,  that is a huge difference. He is 35 years old playing against 23-29 year olds. He is playing 32 minutes for someone that age it's a lot.

About  Butler: What the hell are you talking about getting used to his new body? You act  like this guy just had liposuction and poof he magically lost 40 pounds.  When you lose weight you become lighter and quicker not slower; and how long  will it take good old Jackie to get used to his body? He looks definitely more than 250 pounds. So unless you have a team doctor weigh him, don't make assumptions about his weight!
*    Here are players that weight around 250 Brad Miller 261, Okur 263, Sean Marks, 250, Pat Burke, 250, Duncan, 260, Gasol, 260, Jamaal Maglorie, 259. Now there are a ton of other players but I didn't want to go through the whole NBA. All these players about the same height 6-10 to 7 feet tall. They all weigh about the same, and they are all ten times skinner looking that Butler. So don't make comments about him looking around 250, when he really looks like around 270 or even more!                      

The reason we want to see White play is because he is young and athletic, and he was averaging 17 points per game in the NBDL, and I know he can give the same production Bruce has been giving us. And no one here is saying that Bruce isn't a great defender, but with his age he needs play about 5-8 minutes less so he can be fresh for the playoffs. What White can't play defense, that is the reason the Spurs signed him, not because of his dunking ability.  And to expect him not to give us anything is stupid. Look at the NBA looking at how many young players are contributing to their teams, If he doesn't play you don't know if he can contribute or not. Now if he gets out there and sucks  like some Spurs we know then bench his ass. But not giving him an opportunity is stupid!

You also keep criticizing  anyone on here  who says something bad against the Spurs. I remember about a month ago Aaron wrote that Tony should pass more, and you went on a tangent about that, but then Pop then realized that Tony wasn't getting his teammates involved. Pop has also admitted that Butler has been a huge disappointment this year.  

by adam8065 on Feb 15, 2007 10:53 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
  1. Please learn how to use the reply button.

  2. This isn't just me saying "Bowen isn't as bad as you think he is defensively", the +/- stats back it up as well. This has been his best year since 2002-2003.

The problem is that you have this warped notion of what a defensive stopper really is. He's not going to shut down every player, but he does a fine job 85% of the time. THere's not much more you can ask from a player than that. The fact that you believe that he "never defends anyone who can create their own shot well" speaks volumes. He's defended everyone from Caron Butler, to Joe Johnson, to Zach Randolph, to Josh Howard and even Dwayne Wade well. The problem is, sometimes scorers get hot, and we as fans remember the nights were Bowen get lit up MUCH more than the nights where he shuts his man down. Unless you want to make the argument that 80% of ppl Bowen guards can't create their own shot, I don't see where you're coming from. In the end, I think that the true reason you think Bowen has slowed down is because "well, Stampler said so."

As far as Butler goes, I don't know if he will pan out, but to pan someone on 35 minutes of floor time is ridiculous, almost as ridiculous as the notion that a guy who has played one way all his life - establish position with weight, hold it with bulk - can play as well after he's shed 30 lbs of that bulk. It's like a celloist who suddenly loses range of motion in two of his fingers on his tuning hand. CHanges in the body takes a long time to adjust to. I don't see what's so unreasonable about this statement. The fact that you don't seem to understand it makes me believe that you either never played basketball in your life or that you're just running out of corners to paint yourself into.

James White has a similar problem with BUtler, namely, body size. He's 185 lbs. To put that in perspective, he gives up about 15 lbs to the already diminuitive Bruce Bowen. I saw some of his college games, and there's no doubt that he's fast, but this guy isn't someone like Corey Brewer, who can compensate for his lack of bulk with his body control. White, right now, is really raw. He scored 17.6 in the NBDL, but to put that into perspective, so did guys like Luke Jackson or Will Conroy. Now, should we be giving those guys minutes above Bowen? All you need to score in the NBDL is athleticism. What you should really be looking for is his performances vs other scorers, his rebounding and so forth. Right now, it's clear that he's not ready. FOr him to get playing time, he has to bring something to this team that's not already present. Right now, I don't think he does that. You can scream all you want about his athleticism, but that means exactly shit when his body can't handle contact. I don't think his 185, 6'7" body can handle contact, and it seems a lot of people think that way as well.

All you need to do is find a tape of his games last year vs. the Spurs. THe difference in body type is clearly visible.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 15, 2007 12:50 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
Oh, and link to when Pop said Butler has been disappointing.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 15, 2007 12:51 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
I watch the Spurs play, I see how Bruce's man beat him constantly time and time again.

James White is also listed at 200 pounds, that is a huge difference. What has Finley or Horry brought to the team to deserve that tons of minutes. Yes they have had a couple of good games this year but they are far and few. Now giving him 5 minutes a game isn't going ruin this team, maybe he can actually doing something while he is out on the floor?  

But to dress Butler is unacceptable over White when we all know Butler is out of shape. Another thing Butler does not look like he has lost that much weight to me at all. But I am for him going down to the NBDL so he can get some playing time because he isn't going to get any this year. I wrote about that a while back.

I will have to look for the what Pop said about Butler I don't' have time right now, since I'm at work.

by adam8065 on Feb 15, 2007 2:25 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
He can't go back to the NBDL, teams can only assign players who is within 1st two years of entrance to the league. Remember, Butler averaged a 18-10 in the CBA. That's how easy the NBDL is.

James White weighed in at 185 during pre-draft camps. He weighed in at 190 or so during his time with the Toros. ANd if you had actually watched him play, you'd get a good appreciation of how weak he actually is. Of course, you might not get much, since apparently, you're seeing everyone blow by Bruce. It's not happening. Best +/- defensively since 2003. This is the same shit that we go through every year. Someone will look at the ESPN spurs page and realize Bruce is in his mid 30s. He'll scream and scream about how he's getting worse defensively despite evidence to the contrary. THis year, it's especially ridiculous cause he's posting these #s despite having Fabricio Oberto and Francisco Elson in the paint and Pop falling in love with little guys.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 15, 2007 7:19 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
Oh, and you can't find the link cause he never fucking said it. Pop doesn't throw players not named Beno Udrih under the bus.

If you can't tell the difference in weight between Butler now and Butler a year ago, there's really not much to say. It's really hard to have any meaningful discussion when people avoid things that are staring them right in the face in order to create faux personalities for players they love to attack.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 15, 2007 7:22 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
Okay, maybe Bowen hasn't been as bad defensively as it looks to the naked eye, but in Adam's defense Pop protects him by playing him almost exclusively with Duncan (88.6% of his 1117 minutes) and Parker (82.6%).  

I don't really have a problem with Bowen playing as long as Duncan and another big are out there behind him, as the defense is designed.  

I only get my panties in a bunch when he's out there in a tinyball alignment.  By definition when we go to tinyball it's because we want offense and if we want offense then Bowen can't play.  And without that second big, his defense gets significantly worse.  

The ONLY tinyball line-up this team should ever resort to is Duncan-Finley-Barry-Ginobili-Parker.  If you don't put those five out there together, then don't play tinyball period.  That's all I ask.  

by Aaronstampler on Feb 15, 2007 9:16 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
What faux personality has Adam (or me for that matter) ever given anyone?  

If he called Butler lazy and disappointing it's because he hasn't showed enough in practice to get his butt on the court.  You can compare his situation to Stephen Jackson's all you want, but I think it's disingenuous to think that if the coaches loved Butler's effort to this point that he wouldn't be getting more run.  

Just because he's lost some weight, it doesn't mean he's fulfilling all expectations of him.  Maybe he's not spending as much energy in practice or watching film as the coaches want.  Maybe he still doesn't have the offense and defense down pat.  Maybe he thinks he is being paid just to lose weight and nothing else.  I don't think the coaches are totally happy with his attitude since he had to be told repeatedly by Tim just to help Bonner off the floor when he got hurt in the Wizards game.  

For crying out loud, Oberto's been terrible, Bonner is hurt and Horry is a walking corpse, you really think Pop's happy that he doesn't feel Butler is good enough to play right now?  I suppose the Ely trade is completely unrelated then.

As for White, nobody is labeling him as a savior or the next Scottie Pippen or anything like that.  All anyone is saying is that he possesses two traits - youth and athleticism - that are sorely lacking with the club.  

Hey, compared to Matthew I have major doubts about White.  After all he went to Cincinnati and that university has been known to pump out a steady assembline of knuckleheads.  But I'm willing to give him a chance to see what he can do and like Adam said, throwing him out there for a few minutes with the other starters with the understanding that he'll only touch the ball in transition and off his own efforts on the glass won't hurt anyone.  The coaches I'm sure will remind him the second they see him playing d like his pants aren't on fire, he'll be on the bench.

No personal insults have been thrown Bruce's way.  Nobody's said anything bad about his personality.  Everyone acknowledges he's a good guy and a great teammate.  All anybody said is he's not the player he used to be.  Hardly a crime.

Yes... occasionally some mean things have been said about Tony.  But A) He's said repeatedly, throughout his career he'd rather shoot than pass B) The coach did have to remind him to pass more last month and C) Until he steps his game up in the playoffs there will be only two sacred cows on this team, like it or not.  

I think the reality of the situation is that while Manu and Tony like each other fine off the floor, they don't seem to have great chemistry together on it most of the time.  We're hardly the first people to notice this.  It is a very good thing that they're on good terms away from the floor or it could get ugly out there.  

Either way, I would appreciate it if you kept your discussion with other people here civil.  Whatever negative comments other posters make, they make them about NBA players/coachers, not other posters.  It's just a game and we're just having fun with it.  

by Aaronstampler on Feb 15, 2007 10:08 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
I appreciate the comments Aaron! Let me add, why would I have anything against Butler or Bowen? Maybe if you read some of my old diaries you would know I actually wrote Bruce is the still the  best perimeter defender in the NBA.  I love Bruce and his game, but he should be playing less minutes because of his age!!!! So don't say I love to attack players. You seem to keep making your own assumptions about me even though you don't know me.

You  also keep trying to start something with anyone that questions anything about this team. We all have opinions and whatever we think is whatever we think. And don't write that it's idiotic or stupid, I didn't join this blog to start shit with anyone especially you!

And no sorry I wasn't watching Jackie Butler last year, He was on the Knicks, not on the Spurs I usually don't give a shit about players on other teams!!!!!!!

And the only player I have ever given shit to was Tony because "sometimes" he wants to shoot every time down the floor. Now you can say that is bull but when the Head coach tells he wants to pass more, what can you say about that.

Another thing, I made that part up about what Pop said about Jackie Butler because I'm 27 years old and jealous of him because he is in the NBA and I'm not, you got me there. I admit it, I hate Butler because he took my spot on the Spurs, so I root against him because of it.(Hey Genius I would love for Butler to succeed because Duncan only has a couple of good years left, so if Butler becomes a great  low post player and can help the Spurs contend year in and year out I'm all for it)

I want everyone on the Spurs  to succeed, the only player I ever rooted against earlier this year was Parker when he was just in his scoring mode mentality and never passing to Manu. That being said if players aren't playing well, or not trying out there, I can criticize if I like. If you don't like what I write don't read it. This blog is suppose be for fun. You come on here most of time and are affable but then other times you try to rationalize everything that Pop does, and try to belittle anyone who disagrees with him

It's funny when you tell me to watch White play; sorry I don't get NBDL league games. You tell me not criticize Butler because he has played 35 minutes this year, but you can criticize James White even though he hasn't been given an opportunity to play yet. Like we have all said on here before if White sucks pull him. But when I see Butler play he looks awkward and has no sense on the floor. (I remember you also criticized me earlier this year  when I wanted Tony to pass the ball to Manu even though he wasn't playing well and only getting only 9 shots per game)

One last thing: You are really more annoying than Mark Cuban!

by adam8065 on Feb 15, 2007 11:42 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team
Stampler - It's a double standard that we sometimes have. On one hand, Butler isn't playing because he's fat, his body isn't ready, he's lazy, and he's not shown anything in practice. On the other hand, White isn't playing because we're trying to hold the guy down? Could it be possible that White isn't playing because he's not shown that he was ready either in his time in the NBDL or during the Spurs practice? Is it not possible that the combination of his inability to finish in traffic, his poor rebounding and his tendency to get erased from plays is the reason he's not seeing floortime?

I have a lot of problems with how the Spurs have chosen to develop young players in the last 5 or so years, but I don't think you can say one young player is being benched because of performance while the other is being benched because of shortsightedness without coming off as a bit of a hypocrit.

The fact remains that Stephen Jackson saw 23 games of action despite being on a team whose best swingmen were Danny Ferry and the exhumed corpse of Steve Smith. Like White and Butler, he didn't get a chance to play despite mediocre competition in that spot. I'm not saying that one prospect is better than the other. I am saying that neither of these guys are probably ready, and we should wait till summer league before choosing to spread what are essentially rumors that we have no way to confirm.

I don't think trading for a guy in the last year of his contract (who happens to make LESS than the contract we traded) is indicative of this team's plans. Ely has the advantage over Butler because he's ready to contribute now (or, at the very least, really soon). I think getting him is an indictment on Butler's inexperience, not on his work ethic.

Adam - it doesn't really matter if you don't like Bowen or Butler or anyone else on this team. What matters is that 1) you made up shit to "prove" that they have flaws in their game 2) you choose to criticize without bothering to do any advanced research and 3) when faced with evidence, rather than reexamining your viewpoint, you chose to make up further shit. My problem with you is not anything to do with how you feel about a player, I could really care less. My problem is when people choose to be lazy and pass around the same word-of-mouth rumors rather than doing their own research. That's the problem I had with your post.

Compound that with the fact that you readily admit you've never seen either of these players (Butler or White) play significant amount of minutes. DOesn't that at least suggest to you that perhaps your opinion was a bit hastily formed? It'd be fine if you were a Cinncinnati Fan that'd watched White all his career (and according to some Cinnci fans, he wasn't that great), but to say that you can make an informed opinion on a player by their 35 minutes of play, their body type (which you have no point of reference to, since you've never seen him with another team), and NBDL stats epitomizes what I refered to as laziness. But, whatever, you already have preconcieved opinions on players. Butler is lazy and White is deserving of playing time because he is athletic. Anymore deep insights that you wish to provide?

I don't want to further this shitfest, so I'll just end it with these 2 things. First, I have to say I've also criticized this team a fair amount this year, and it's rather disingenous (and lazy) to say that I'm a blind homer that defends the team. My defense of Tony Parker isn't because I think he's a flawless point guard, but rather, that I think he simply doesn't have the natural playmaker talent or awareness that you need to be a pass-first point guard. A good example is the fast break he had with Elson vs. Detroit. He had a decent-sized hole to get the ball through, and he did, but the problem is, he hit Elson when Elson was already under the basket. We've seen guys like Baron Davis or Steve Nash turn that fastbreak into a dunk. The fact that Tony missed Elson in front of the basket and only hit him when he was under the basket shows the difference between those three players (Parker, Nash and Davis). Tony just doesn't have the awareness that those guys do. ANd it's not just one play, it's been happening all season. I can't count how many times TOny's missed Manu cutting down the lane or an open guy on the opposite side of the court. Tony can make passes when he's got a clear line of vision and/or a good idea of where a guy is suppose to be. He can't see the floor nearly as well as Nash or Chris Paul or even a guy like Brevin Knight. In that way, I think the criticism of Parker is misguided in that you're asking him to be something he clearly cannot be - a pass first point guard. He just doesn't have the vision, so why bother talking about it at all. Forgive me, but I don't see the point of repeatedly ragging a player who is producing despite his flaws. I also don't see the point of being angry at Tony every year for something he hasn't improved since his first 2-3 years in the league, especially since this team has so many other problems that are the cause of their mediocre (though similar to 2003) record.

I'd also like to make it clear that when I refer to something as absurd and ridiculous, I'm saying your claims, not your persons are ridiculous. I'm sorry if that's not clear enough. I'll try to make the distinction in the future. And yes, I do think you take stuff too far. Let's not forget that you've wished injury on our own players (Finley, off the top of my head) before. Let's not play the good fan/bad fan card, shall we?

by FirebatM3 on Feb 16, 2007 9:55 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team
Stampler - as far as Bowen goes, then we agree. Small ball should consist of 4 wing players that can score or rebound or, hopefully, do both. Bruce effectiveness is limited when we choose to play small ball, that much is obvious.

To be fair, though, Tim is having one of his worse defensive years (though still amazing by normal standards) while Bruce is having one of his best. I still think that it shows all the talk of Bruce needs to be played less is overblown, especially since we have no one on the roster that can make a capable replacement.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 16, 2007 9:59 AM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
The reason White has never seen any minutes is because he was signed after training camp and never practiced with the team. That was why Pop sent him down to the NBDL. If you look early on the Spurs Schedule they have had much time to practice, so they could never see what he could do as a player.

The reason they called White  up is because during the rodeo trip they have had ample time to practice. So don't compare his to Jackson who was with the whole team from Summer league and preseason these are two different scenarios. Pop even said he called White up because they have some time days off during the Rodeo trip and he wants to see what White can do.

And don't say I make shit up, sorry I don't have time to search the internet to look for an article that was printed probably over a month ago just to appease you, because you believe Butler has work ethic and isn't fat!

About Tony: No he doesn't need to have a fantastic vision to come down the floor and pass to an open teammate instead of taking shot after shot. So it's alright for Tony to come down and have one of the big's set a screen for him so then he can dribble around and around and then shot it? Then why not move Tony to shooting Guard if that is what he is good for? So Pop must be an idiot for specifically telling Tony to start looking for his teammates more and start shooting less. I wish Pop would have told me sooner that Tony wasn't a pass-first point guard, because that is news to me?

Also, Tony does have court vision, you can't say why didn't he throw an alley-up to Elson because Nash would have, Elson and Amare are two different players. If we had Amare or Marion, Parker would be throwing lobs up left and right!

And no I haven't been on Tony's case for a while because he has actually been distributing to his teammates, since Pop talked to him. The only reason I brought him is because you say I like to attack players.

The Michael Finley comment was a joke, I also said if Manu killed Tony I would be his defense Lawyer.   And since this site is supposed to be fun I can say whatever I want. I will call Butler fat because he is; I will call Tony selfish, when he states he wants to shoot the ball all the time instead of distributing, which is what his job is.  I will call Tim a cry baby when he whines to the refs if they call a foul on him; I will scream at Finley when he misses every shot but keeps chucking it up every time he touches it.  I will yell when Manu becomes turnover prone or just starts chucking up 3's every time he touches the ball. I will call Bowen worthless when he gets lit up and gives us nothing on the offensive end!  

Sorry I don't feel sorry for players that are getting paid millions of dollars and not getting the job done!

by adam8065 on Feb 16, 2007 12:42 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
You know what, this is the last post, but let's just draw a brief logic diagram here, shall we?

James White was not here for training camp, unlike Stephen Jackson --> James White has shown less than Stephen Jackson in practice, according to Pop (Pop Show, yesterday)--> James White is behind better players than Stephen Jackson was --> AND YET JAMES WHITE IS MORE READY TO CONTRIBUTE THAN STEPHEN JACKSON?

One of those points did not progress logically. Which one? So despite the fact that James White was bad in summerleague, mediocre in NBDL, and had two of the better coaches in the NBA (pop and Carlisle, as well as Larry Bird) decided that he wasn't ready to contribute, what makes you think otherwise? Cause he can dunk? Cause Matthew said so?

so let's review. Adam's opinion apparently > Empirical evidence, professional scouts, two of the better coaches in the NBA, past precedence, past results and the opinions of countless people who's actually watched James White play. Good to know.

Look, I'm just going to say this, Tony has no great courtvision, and most of the time, he doesn't make a pass cause he probably can't see it. I find it useless to repeatedly bash a guy for something when it has become clear he can do little to change it. Right now, he's playing as a pass-first guy to start the games, but his assist #s are still low and he's still making mistakes/missing open guys. It's pointless to keep hammering him about it cause it's just focusing on what a player can't do, rather than what he does very well. There's a difference if he can improve in that area, but I have seen little evidence that he can. Maybe you have, who knows. It's a moot point anyways.

I also find the "I'm too busy to look up the article" argument absolutely hilarious. So you're argument for not being able to find a non-existent article is because you're too busy. It's called the Search function, the Express-News has it. I did it, all there is is some conjecture from Johnny Ludden. This conversation is useless since empirical evidence and logic obviously mean different things to us. I'll just say good day, and look forward to Summerleague, cause i guarantee you that's the time when Butler and White will both show their stuff, because that's the earliest either of them is going to be ready/able to get playing time.

by FirebatM3 on Feb 16, 2007 7:07 PM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
If anything, I think you're being too hard on Tony.  You're making him out to be practically blind out there on the court.  He doesn't have Nash's court vision, but he's not that bad.  

He sees the open guy lots of times. Sometimes his decision making on 3 on 1s isn't very good and his alley-oop passes aren't the most accurate and sometimes he gets himself in trouble in traffic, but overall I would say his court vision is no better or worse than most of the starting point guards.

With him, I hate to say it, some games he just looks like he's making a conscious effort to look for open guys and other games he just looks to score.  Especially if he hits a couple in a row, he's just gonna keep putting it up.  It's not a vision thing, it's a personality thing.  

I think he has the ability to be averaging 7 or 8 assists a game easily, even with the offense dumping the ball to Timmy a bunch of times.  But I think Manu should be averaging more assists too.  Really the only guy's passing I've been pleased with this year is Tim's.

by Aaronstampler on Feb 18, 2007 2:56 AM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team! What an Accomplish
In the words of the immortal Apu Nahasapeemapetilon, save your precious hatred for the game. The stresses of the season so far have been substantial, to be sure. But let's all remember who the real enemy is here.

by schwazz on Feb 17, 2007 11:39 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team!
My last comment:

I don't even want talk about James White, because you can't guarantee  he is ready to contribute or not. The Pacers were stacked at that position, period. That is why the cut him. Pop was fortunate to get him, after he was cut, so he wasn't even supposed to be on this team. So you can't say he is ready to contribute or not, because he was cut by the Pacers. And why did Pop call him back up if he isn't ready or showing some progress. That's my two cents on that.

But don't tell me that Tony doesn't see the court at all because that is ridiculous.  Tony isn't 5 feet 2 inches out there he is 6 feet 2. His teammates are pretty tall also. Over the past couple of years Tony has wanted to become more of a scorer, plain and simple. Tony can see the court just fine, I always see Tony make great passes to his teammates when he takes it in the middle and is about to get blocked? So he can see teammates sometimes and not others, sorry I don't buy that at all.  Like Aaron said when Tony wants to get assists he easily can.  Detroit was a perfect example of it. In the first half he had 5 assists second 3rd quarter he kept shooting the ball.

Tony Has been playing professional Basketball since he was 17 years old. Do you actually believe the he would have lasted this long he didn't have court vision. Why would the Spurs have signed him, he if couldn't and still can't find his teammates because he didn't become a scorer since only a couple of years ago. Everyone knows Tony likes to shoot the ball, he admits that he wants to shoot the ball; he would rather shoot than pass, period.  Tony begins games getting his teammates involved in the second half he likes go into scoring mode.  Everyone in the league considers Tony a shooting point guard now, and that has nothing to do with his inability to see the court. This is the NBA the best basketball players in the world play here. I'm sorry Tony would never had made it to the NBA if he doesn't have court vision. IF you can't find open teammates you won't even make the NBA let alone last this long.

by adam8065 on Feb 18, 2007 5:07 PM CST reply actions   0 recs

Re: Yes! We Beat a Shitty Team! What an Accomplish
Tony's court vision is so bad he had 10 assists last night.

by JamesR on Feb 19, 2007 10:42 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the San Antonio Spurs.

Community Guidelines
Start posting about the Spurs »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Spurromeo_small
Bite the Bullet?
Black_small
Ginobili vs. Dracula, Chapter 4
0910_bonner_sandwich_small
Warning: Blair Rebounding (Wallpaper)
Small
In Praise of Complementary Players
The_big_four_small
Bella's quirky musings... allas version

Recent FanPosts

Sbn-avatar_small
NBA Live 10 Gameday Poll:: Regular Season Week 5 (4 Games)
D-rob1_small
Unofficial Spurs/Mavs Recap
Sbn-avatar_small
NBA Live 10 Simulation (4):: San Antonio Spurs @ Dallas Mavericks
Bunnycookie_small
Tuesdays are for Losers
Bunnycookie_small
Rainy Days and Monday Loser Threads Always Get Me Down
Halloween_06_028_small
Proposed Lineup

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Featured Poll

Poll
Who has the best hair in the NBA?

  974 votes | Results

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recommended FanShots

48MoH: Early Assessment of Team D

Recent FanShots

Jolt by Mason may be what Spurs need
SI.com: Gregg Popovich's influence spreads wide across NBA
Grim article about Ginobili (plus Manu's reaction on FB)
Harvey: Fire Pop? That Was The Last Time...
True Hoop> Bruce Bowen on dirty play
Ginobili out; Parker doubtful
Craziness at 48MoH
Eva Longoria Earns Philanthropist Of The Year Award For 2009
nba.com> Raptors claim Mensah-Bonsu off waivers from Houston
True Hoop> Shane Battier, King of the Quad

+ New FanShot All FanShots >


Coach

Ats_big_small Wayne Vore (ATS)

Player

Supergino_small LatinD

Doas_small jollyrogerwilco

Bunnycookie_small Lauri

Oberto_fab_small silverandblack_davis

Roadavatar_small Tim C.

4558041c970_main200_small CapHill

Announcer

Manucrazy_small Aaronstampler

Zoe_spurs1_small BlaseE

Small CECabrera21

Profile_5_small Fred Silva